
Richard Caten, CEO of Ardent, explains why planning reform alone won’t solve the UK’s infrastructure delivery challenges
Imagine a place with a national blueprint and a tangible plan to secure £1 trillion in mobile global funds as inward investment for infrastructure project delivery, through dedicated co-funding vehicles that will attract private and public sector backing.
Added to that, this utopia has a capital-centric framework and a major projects office that is dedicated to solving the problem of planning friction.
This land of milk and honey isn’t a figment of my over-optimistic imagination. This is Canada under Mark Carney, the former Governor of the Bank of England, where a pipeline of projects adds up to this colossal sum in Canadian dollars.
Cross-party visions
It’s been made possible by Canada doing what we in the UK have not done. The revolving door into 10 Downing Street and the House of Commons, and the constant piecemeal changes to planning reform in the last few years, have been to the utter detriment of our infrastructure delivery.
Instead, Canada has a long-term vision for delivery, with cross-party support that extends beyond the next 25 years and will be unaffected by different iterations of government and changes in leadership.
The uncertainty that has plagued the UK and undermined infrastructure delivery, as well as investment and the efficiency of our economy as a whole, makes the UK less competitive on the global stage. This should worry every citizen.
Regulatory stability and avoiding policy volatility are crucial if our infrastructure is to improve. The UK’s lack of a stable government, stable policy, and stable taxation has been, and continues to be, a disaster for our infrastructure.
For a significant proportion of the last 30 years, we have been the lowest investors in the G7, while simultaneously having the third-largest population growth behind the US and Canada and their huge land masses. This is why nothing in this country, from mobile phone networks to water to trains to roads, works: we have not invested at the same rate as our population has grown.
Each successive government has merely fussed with the planning regime rather than fundamentally changed it. Not one of them has radically altered the planning process so it can actually deliver the outputs the country is crying out for. Instead, bolt-on reforms are implemented, following which everyone has to learn new rules which don’t really make much of a material difference.
It could all be so different. We could be living in a country with cross-party visions that support the nation and address citizens’ concerns and the impending issues they’ll have to deal with, be they energy security, the cost of energy, or even whether they’ll be able to travel around the country easily.
Remember that the next time you’re standing in the vestibule of a train to London in the middle of nowhere that hasn’t moved for 20 minutes, with no mobile signal.
Where’s the money coming from?
The mobile capital Canada has access to is a key part of the jigsaw. Renewable energy sources, for example, need to leverage global private sector money. Investors will only do so in countries and territories where they expect the best returns.
Without a sense of stability across the board, the UK attracts a risk premium. We become less investable than countries that take the longer, broader view of their own horizons.
British solar and onshore wind farms used to attract significant investment, particularly the latter, which first began generating power from a farm of turbines in Cornwall in November 1991. But then, in 2025, almost overnight, the first-come, first-served system that dictated how these sources of energy connected to the grid changed.
The grid was unable to cope with the strain being placed on it; an unmanageable backlog formed because there was not enough capacity to accommodate every proposed project. Upgrading the network demanded significant investment, planning permission and time. Some projects faced delays of years while others received connection dates far into the future.
The queuing system and ‘first ready and needed, first connected’ notion which replaced these connections makes sense, but was only necessary because the damage was done. The change has caused mobile capital to move to other countries in the short term, with an expectation that it will return over the medium term because now there is greater certainty, and that’s what is needed.
The lack of stability spreads
Our problems with stability spread inexorably through the infrastructure landscape. We need to bring in a workforce of around 650,000 to deliver the country’s infrastructure needs. Chopping and changing regulatory matters undermines that need.
Political uncertainty also increases costs when projects need to be redesigned, paused or restarted. Contracts need to be renegotiated, delays increase labour and material costs, and contractors may charge more as they factor in this uncertainty.
There’s also the regional inequality that political instability brings. The irony of the HS2 network north of Birmingham being scrapped in a speech that was delivered in Manchester was not lost, as its cancellation affected plans for improved connectivity across the Midlands and the North.
Spending isn’t investing
Spending money is not the same as investing it. Infrastructure is an investment expenditure because it enables efficiency and returns something to the economy. The propensity to throw money at creaking services is operational expenditure that just keeps the system going, however inefficiently.
Recognising the need for investment expenditure would undoubtedly mean having to make tough, unpopular decisions. But balanced with the needs of the entire country, now and in years to come, these are the nettles that a government must grasp. The impetus must be to deliver changes that improve the lives of not just our current communities but our future generations too.
Continuity and long-term commitments are the key to a country which works smoothly; otherwise, we risk delays, wasted resources, and continued inequality. Looking to the Canadian example is the first step.
The post Instability in infrastructure project planning: Why we should all be worried appeared first on Planning, Building & Construction Today.